Last weekend the weather was mostly nice and we spent plenty of time outside. Leo and Ellie are good at playing independently in the back yard, with minimal interference from me for good little chunks of time. It’s those little spaces of freedom that allow me the luxury to daydream. And spy on my neighbors of course.
So there was my neighbor (I’ll call her “N.”) going shopping with her mother. They boarded the shiny black SUV parked in the driveway, giddy, giggling and chatting, a day of retail opportunity and mother-daughter bonding stretched out in front of them. Hours later they returned home with overflowing bags from the farmer’s market, fresh kale and apples and boxes of bulk items from Costco too. I imagined days and nights of side by side cooking, and more chatting.
There were bags from clothing stores too. A Children’s Place, Gap Kids. They’d gone to the mall. Of course they had. Grandma was visiting. They were kid-free too. N.’s husband had apparently opted to give her the gift of a break from the children, to enjoy her mother’s company, untethered.
Later in the afternoon they would gather outside for an evening meal. This time it was the whole family. N’s husband, the two small boys and of course, N’s mother. Wine glasses and bottles of red were carried on trays, outside to the deck. The grill was fired up and soon the air was filled with the intoxicating aroma of steak on a late summer night. And I don’t even particularly like steak.
For many years after my mother died, the favorite picture I had of the two of us together was an image so mundane that it’s almost laughable, really. My stepfather took it. I actually think it was a "test shot" for one of his new cameras. We are standing in the dining room of her old Craftsman bungalow in Portland. I am about 25, which made my mother 47. She would be dead in three years. We are peering at the entertainment section of the Sunday Oregonian, trying to decide which movie to see. The day is stretched out in front of us, nothing we had to do except of course, decide on a movie and oh yes, where to go after for coffee? It was something so simple and easy and taken for granted. Like grocery shopping or trip to the mall.
It’s a nothing photo, really. And when my mother was alive, I wouldn’t have given it a second glance. But with her gone? It stood framed on a prominent bookshelf for many years. During one of our many moves it was packed away and I haven’t been able to find it.
What I grew to love about that photo was how ordinary it was. It was just a day. A lazy Sunday spent with my mom, a day like so many. Who would think they would ever end? Or at least, that they wouldn’t last for a very long time?
What more is there to say? Watching N. with her mom, I contemplate a visit from my mom now and what that would be like. She would hardly recognize my life now. There is very little time for contemplation of anything, certainly not much room for movies or coffee spots or leisurely shopping trips. In spite of all that, I think she’d be both surprised and pleased with what fills up the spaces now.
And yes, of course it’s impossibly tempting to romanticize that visit she never got to take, to gloss over the missed shopping trips that would surely be free of conflict or disagreements or sour moods. But such is the “luxury” of grief and loss. In your mind, when you’re imagining how things could have been? You can have the story play out exactly as you want it.
I miss her more, this time of year. I always do. The season is changing. The milestones of another school year and all the excitement and emotion that brings, is upon us. It’s in the fall, too, that I’m reminded of her last visit to New York, eleven years ago this November. It was seven months before she died, four months before anyone even knew she was sick. We spent a whirlwind long weekend together and unknowingly packed every minute in as if it would be our last “trip” together which of course I now marvel at and am so grateful for. She took me shopping at Macy’s where she bought me my first “grownup” winter coat, we ate Indian food twice, closed down several museums, sampled pickles on the Lower East Side and walked until our feet throbbed. I was in my honeymoon phase with New York. I was living my dream and couldn’t wait to share it with her. And all of that feels like it was a hundred years ago, another lifetime, truly.
Another holiday season approaches (pumpkins and ghost are cropping up in the windows and yards of my suburban neighborhood), which is always sweet and at the same time, bittersweet. And of course, her birthday. This week she would be sixty. She didn’t even get to turn fifty. So many mundane weekends we didn’t get to spend together, going to the movies, meeting for coffee after, to discuss. All those idealized mother-daughter shopping trips never taken. I can just imagine her buying clothes for her grandchildren. Her grandchildren.
Yes, it is what it is. It should get easier with every passing year and in a way, it does. But it still doesn’t feel any more fair. It never will. Life can be so sweet, life is so precious, but nobody ever said it was fair.
My mom, Eleanor, Japan, 1995 (photo by Rick Regan)
And so today, more than other days, I’m daydreaming of the mundane and what a gift it is. And I’m thinking of a life merely only half lived, and of two little lives my mom never had the pleasure of meeting.
Pumpkin picking, fall, 2009
Happy Birthday, Mom.